Early diagnosis of Alzheimer's key, but obstacles remain
Ljubljana, 20 September - Early detection of Alzheimer's disease is a stated objective in Slovenia and instrumental for providing treatment in the early stages of the disease. However, it is estimated that three quarters of all patients remain undiagnosed. There are several obstacles to early detection, including lack of staff and expensive diagnostics.
Figures on how many people have Alzheimer's, which is responsible for about 60% of all dementia cases, are hard to come by. A dementia registry planned in the national dementia management strategy does not exist yet, which leaves experts with guestimates at best.
Štefanija Lukič Zlobec, the head of the Alzheimer awareness association Spominčica, estimates there are 33,000-34,000 dementia patients in Slovenia, whereby three quarters of those with early signs of the disease are undiagnosed and do not receive proper support or treatment.
Those who are diagnosed typically have such advanced dementia that it is no longer possible to mitigate symptoms with anti-dementia drugs.
"Because the symptoms are so mild at the beginning and individuals do not see a doctor, most diagnoses come at a more advanced stage of the disease, when they already have serious problems and soon become dependent on others," she says.
Diagnosis is the slogan of this year's World Alzheimer's Day.
There has been some headway in recent years. Dr Martin Rakuša, a neurologist at the University Medical Centre Maribor who works with dementia patients, says that "we have overcome the nihilism that grandma has dementia and there is nothing we can do about it."
"If we can give a 75-year-old five years of relatively cognitively sound life, we have done a lot. Such a person can function normally in the home environment," he says.
An awareness-raising campaign by Spominčica in 2017-2018 resulted in a slight increase in the number of people getting treatment. Alas, its effect has already waned, according to Rakuša.
Lack of staff, expensive diagnostics
But even if there is sufficient awareness among the population about the need to see a doctor at the first sign of dementia, little will be achieved unless there are enough doctors to treat them.
"If they have to wait for treatment for too long, it's of no use if everyone knows they have to see a doctor as soon as memory problems appear," says Rakuša.
There are only 150 neurologists in Slovenia, and about twice as many psychiatrists, but there are very few clinical psychologists, who treat and diagnose Alzheimer's disease and dementia.
Since 2018 GPs can treat dementia with anti-dementia drugs without a prior diagnosis by a specialist neurologists or psychiatrists, but in their role as the gateway to secondary healthcare, they are chronically overstretched.
The situation is likely to improve with the emerging new network of mental health centres for adults and specialist departments at the secondary level in accordance with the National Mental Health Resolution 2018-2028, but this is still a work in progress.
Diagnostics have been improving fast, according to Rakuša. In both primary and secondary care, doctors diagnose Alzheimer's either with lab analyses of cerebrospinal fluid or with MR and CT scans of the brain.
Scanning is less invasive, but it is significantly more expensive: a single CT scan costs 2,000 euro, a cerebrospinal fluid analysis costs just a few hundred euros.
"The question is who will pay. About 50,000 people have moderate or subjective cognitive disorders, examining everyone would cost 2,000 euros apiece," Rakuša says.
Biomarkers in blood are a major recent advancement in Alzheimer's diagnostics and hold great promise as a screening technique: in future, GPs could prescribe exams for certain biomarkers, which would show whether a person has a greater risk of developing Alzheimer's.
However, biomarker tests are not conducted in Slovenia yet. According to Rakuša, they are expensive, at about a thousand euros per test, and were such a screening programme to be introduced, special laboratories would be needed as well, costing hundreds of times as much.
Emerging drugs highlight need for faster diagnostics
As present, a cerebrospinal fluid analysis can take months because to save money, samples are analysed in batches rather than individually. Once a diagnosis is made, treatment can start immediately with existing anti-dementia drugs.
"But once a biopharmaceutical is available, if we indeed get it next year, waiting for months for the results of a cerebrospinal liquid test will not be acceptable," Rakuša says.
A new anti-dementia drug called aducanumab, the first drug that not only treats symptoms but actually targets the underlying causes of Alzheimer's, has already received accelerated approval by the US Food and Drug Administration. The European Medicines Agency has not reached a decision yet.
But to ensure sufficient capacity for early diagnosing of Alzheimer's, in terms of staff and diagnostics, requires serious financial injections and systemic action, according to Rakuša.
"If you compare the overall cost of care for a single dementia patient with the price of diagnostics, diagnostics is cheap," he says, pointing to financial savings and the benefits to families of people functioning normally in the home environment instead of being committed to an institution.
Similarly, Lukič Zlobec says that each person with advanced dementia requires three to four caregivers, typically family members. "Dementia is the most expensive disease in the world. It is long-lasting, family are exhausted, and there are no effective drugs as yet. It is important for the country to adopt a strategy in which it will determine how we are going to address these things."
Strategy coming up
The Health Ministry says a dementia strategy covering the period until 2030 will be finalised by December. It will come with two-year action plans and estimates of financial needs.
One of the goals of the strategy will be to set up a national dementia registry, which is crucial since good data is needed to plan and implement health policy.
But as Rakuša points out, before the registry is set up, it is necessary to tackle staffing issues and diagnostics, else the registry itself will be in vain.
The need for good data and targeted policies is highlighted by growing outlays. The national health insurer issued prescriptions for dementia-related drugs and services worth EUR 4.4 million last year, and it paid hospitals almost EUR 680,000 for the treatment of 102 dementia patients.
Alas, these are just the direct costs. The overall costs are just rough estimates, but they are all an order of magnitude higher. A 2010 study by researchers led by Jure Bon estimated the total direct and indirect costs of all brain disease, not just dementia, at almost EUR 2.5 billion.
Dementia and Covid
The Covid-19 pandemic has made the situation even worse, warns Lukič Zlobec. For many, the condition deteriorated due to social isolation. But beyond that, it is becoming increasingly clear that Covid-19 itself affects the brain.
Rakuša notes that cognitive decline is common in patients with severe Covid, but similar effects can be observed with any severe viral infection. It is not clear, however, why patients who have had Covid report "brain fog".
So far, SARS-CoV-2 has not been isolated in cerebrospinal fluid, which means it does not act as a neurotoxin. Yet the cytokine storm, a frequent condition in severe Covid cases, damages veins, including in the brain.
Images of such patients' brains show characteristic changes: reduced metabolism in the frontal lobe, says Rakuša. Luckily, most patients completely recover, but there will definitely be a certain percentage of patients who will have permanent brain damage.